| |
Why Emulate Film Grain? |
|
|
Three reasons:
1. Digital cameras produce grainless images (though they can be
noisy).
2. Film grain can be very beautiful and convey texture and mood.
3. Photoshop's gaussian noise, or other noise, is very ugly.
Below you can see a sample of Power Retouche Film Grain for comparison
with noise. The gaussian noise is, well, nothing but noise. The
PR film grain on the other hand is pure texture and vibrato -- as
it should be. Please compare the two Power Retouche samples with
the real film grain below.

Gaussian noise
|

Gaussian noise
|

Power Retouche Film Grain plug-in
|

Power Retouche Film Grain plug-in
|
Grain is often considered at its best in B&W images or color
images of low saturation. Here it gives not only texture, but also
mood. I hope the examples below will show color images can benefit
from grain too. |
|
| |
Real Film Grain |
|
| |
Compare these six samples with the
two Power Retouche samples above. Remember PR Film Grain let's you
adjust contrast and size to produce any grain desired. What you
should look for when comparing is texture and "feel" and
how unified the grain is in an overall vibrant surface.

TriX
|

TMax
|

Old film
|

Old film
|

Kodak
|

Kodak
|
|
|
| |
The Film Grain Plug-ins' controls |
|
Grain
controls
B/W grain
Color grain |
 
As you can see, the Film Grain Plug-in has two
identical sets of controls, one set makes the black & white
grain, the other the color grain. The top checkbox turns the entire
group on or off.
|
|
Intensity |
This slider ranges from 0 to 100
and changes the degree to which grain will be apparent in the image.
It does not change the amount of grain pr. square centimeter.
|
|
Grain
Size |
This sets the general size of the
grain. In reality grains do not have a strictly uniform size and
likewise our Film Grain Plug-in will create varied
grain. |
|
Contrast |
In the BW-Grain this will make the
difference between light and dark grains more pronounced.
In the Color Grain it will primarily make the grains more or less
saturated, but it will also make light-dark differences more pronounced. |
|
Photographic
Distribution |
This checkbox will change the distribution of the
grain to emulate the grain distribution in film as it varies at
different brightness levels. When off, grain will be distributed
evenly. In both cases you can adjust the distribution to taste with
the three Retouch Levels sliders. In Photographic Distribution,
the whites and blacks do not get any grain. |
|
Light
Soft <--> Hard |
This slider emulates the way the
light in the darkroom projector can manipulate the appearance of
the film grain. It can make the grain softer or harder. |
|
Retouch
Levels |
The three Retouch Levels sliders (Lights, Mid tones,
Darks) are common to most Power Retouche plug-ins. They regulate
how strongly the retouching should be present in the respective
levels of brightness. By turning Photographic Mode on or off and
using these sliders, you can create your own grain distribution.
You can of course save it as a preset for later use. |
|
Show
Grain
Different color grain for different image modes |
This
checkbox toggles the preview between drawing the grain on the source
image or on a neutral medium gray background. You can choose between
viewing the B/W grain or the color grain. Of course, this requires
the BW grain or color grain are on. If you have turned BW grain
off and select Show Grain and pick the B/W grain, then you will
simply see the original source image. Likewise with color grain
off.
| 
Show B/W grain
|

Show color grain (RGB)
|

Show color grain (Lab).
(See also sample below)
|

Show color grain (CMYK).
|
As you can see from the three color examples, the color grain
is different depending on the image mode you use. This way you have
more choices of effect. The grain in a RGB image will tend towards
red, green and blue. The grain in a Lab image will tend towards
yellow, magenta, cyan and green and will have higher contrast. Grain
in a CMYK image will be very slight and tend towards cyan, magenta
and yellow.
Note that pure color grain in RGB will inevitably
have some BW grain also.
It is special in Lab mode that pure color grain will be without
any brightness value variation. You can add that with BW grain. |

If you in Lab mode combine color grain with BW grain, this
is the result.
|
|
|
|
|
Examples of B&W Film Grain
|
|
Grayscale
image without and with B&W film grain in photographic distribution |
This nice grayscale image would
improve with a bit of grain. The smooth, even slick, appearance
of the mid tones does not suit neither the clouds nor the mood.
This example illustrates Photographic Distribution.
Notice how the intensity (presence) of the grain changes with varying
brightness levels. Pure black and pure white has no grain in film,
nor in our photographic distribution. If you need grain in the lights
or darks, turn photographic distribution off and use the Retouch
Levels to create your own grain distribution.

Original
|

With slight grain
|
|
|
Soft Film Grain
Hard Film Grain |
These two examples illustrate soft
film grain versus hard film grain, but you will also notice that
(true to nature) the soft film grain appears larger than the hard
film grain.

Soft film grain
|

Hard film grain
|
|
|
Film
grain in color images |
Though film grain is mostly utilized
in grayscale images, it can give a nice quality to color images
also. If you just use B/W film grain in a color image, the grain
will not be integrated but will appear to float on top of the colors;
not nice! So with color images either use B/W film grain together
with color film grain or just use color film grain alone.
In this RGB example we only used color film grain and still with
photographic distribution. Notice how the grain enhances the mood
by adding a slight vibrato.

Original
|

Slight color film grain (RGB)
|
The problem here is, that even though it's photo-technically correct
not to have grain in the dark blue clouds, it is aesthetically not
pleasing in this particular image. So we will have to use the retouch
levels and turn Photographic Distribution off. See below. |
|
Retouch levels |

Here we used the retouch levels to add a slight grain to
the dark blue clouds. To the right you can see the settings
we used.
|

These are the settings we used
|
|
|
| |
B&W Grain or Color Grain? |
|
| |

Above: Original image. Below: Color grain only (RGB)
Above: Color grain only (RGB). Below B/W grain only
As you can see from the above two examples, the effect
of adding either B&W grain or color grain is very different.
In general you will find that with color images, even when they
are as low in color as this one, color grain works better than B&W
grain. This is because, as you can see, pure B&W grain in a
color image tends to sort of float above the colors. On the other
hand, if you want strong grain in a color images, then using color
grain alone will not work well because the colored grains will stand
out. In this case you need to enhance with B&W grain. When combined
with color grain, B&W grain will not stand out in color images. |
|
| |
|
|
|
Here's the classic Zebra, that
used to come with Photoshop. It is photographed in such a manner
that the zebra is in focus and the background blurred. The problem
with this is that the blurred background becomes overly smooth and,
at least in my view, becomes a sore spot for the eye. It's just
so slick, it acts like a green piece of paper onto which a cut out
zebra has been pasted. Adding some medium sized grain (BW in Photographic
Mode) will fix this.

Original
|

PR Film Grain
|
|
|
 |
 |
|